Unlocking the Purpose of Divine Tests: Insights from Midrashic Commentary on Genesis 22:1
We read, “Now it came to pass after these things that God tested Abraham…” (Genesis 22:1, NKJV).[i]
This verse provides a somewhat puzzling question. If God is omniscient, meaning that He is all-knowing, why must He test Abraham? And, if He already knows the outcome of the test with Abraham, then why is the test even necessary? We will turn to Midrashic commentary; Genesis Rabba 55:2, to discover an answer.[ii]
The Petihta, i.e., prooftext:
“God will test the righteous, but the wicked and he who loves violence, His soul despises” (Psalm 11:5).
The first Mashal of R. Yonatan:
R. Yonatan said:
A flax worker, when his flax is blighted, doesn’t beat it very much,
because [if he beats it too much], it splinters.
But he beats it a lot when his flax is [of] good [quality].
Why? Because it improves and continues (to improve, the more he beats it).
Thus, the Holy One blessed be He does not test the wicked.
Why? Because they cannot [with]stand the test, as it says,
“And the wicked are banished like the sea…” (Isaiah 57:20).
And whom does He test? The righteous, as it says:
“God will test the righteous…”
“And it was after these things, the wife of his master lifted up her eyes…” (Genesis 39:7).
The second Mashal of R. Yonatan:
“And it was after these things…” (Genesis 22:1).
R. Yonatan said:
When he checks (the contents of) his kiln, the potter doesn’t check the defective pots.
Why? Because he doesn’t get a chance to strike them even once before he breaks them.
And what does he check? Well-made pots,
because even if he strikes them several times, he doesn’t break them.
Thus, the Holy One blessed be He does not test the wicked, but rather the righteous, as it says:
“God will test the righteous…”
The Mashal of R. Elazar:
R. Elazar said:
[This may be compared] to a householder who had two cows,
one strong and one weak.
Upon whom will he place the yoke?
Not upon the strong one!?
The Holy One blessed be He tests the righteous, as it says:
“God will test the righteous…”
This lengthy Midrashic commentary has three Meshalim (Parables) of how God tests the righteous: a flax worker who beats his flax, a potter who strikes his well-made pots, and a householder who places his yoke upon the strong cow. God does and will test His children. God tested Israel in the wilderness. For us who are in Christ, the church, we also find ourselves in situations where we are tested through trial and tribulation. “In this you greatly rejoice, though now for a little while, if need be, you have been grieved by various trials, that the genuineness of your faith, being much more precious than gold that perishes, though it is tested by fire, may be found to praise, honor, and glory at the revelation of Jesus Christ” (1Peter 1:6-7).
It is essential to recognize that self-inflicted tribulation is not from God. Our intentional sin through willful disobedience has its self-destructive consequences. King David certainly learned this lesson the hard way. And yet, God will use every circumstance to mold and transform our character.
The first thing we see in the Midrash is the repetition of Psalm 11:5: “God tests the righteous…but the wicked His soul despises [hates].” It is not a comparison but a contrast, so the inescapable conclusion is that God loves the righteous, and therefore His testing is out of love. It will be the theme of the three Meshalim, yet each will focus on a different type of divine testing as a unique and sometimes painful experience: a beating, a blow, and a yoke. Let us now explore the three Meshalim, first matching the metaphoric elements of the Mashal and the Nimshal:
The first Mashal of R. Yonatan describes the process for making linen, a highly valued fabric made from the fibers of the flax plant. The manufacturing process is laborious. First, the flax is soaked until the outer cover softens. Then, it is beaten until the fibers fluff up enough to be spun into a thread. R. Yonatan contrasts the flax of blighted and good quality. If beaten, the blighted flax will splinter rather than turn into fiber. The good flax, however, is beaten considerably more because the more it is beaten, the higher the fiber quality.
At one level of the Mashal, we see the righteous are taken through a process of transformation from raw material to one that is refined. Thus, Divine trials are for the improvement of the righteous. However, a deeper examination reveals more. R. Yonatan opens the Mashal by explaining that the wicked are not tested because they cannot withstand the test. But the righteous God tests without giving any explanation. From our world-centered viewpoint, we might expect that God wants to improve us, and He does, but does He test us for our glory or His? For this reason, R. Yonatan is more concerned with explaining why the wicked are not tested rather than explaining why the righteous are.
R. Yonatan explains the wicked being banished like the sea, for its waters cannot be still, and they cast up dirt and mud. “They are clouds without water, carried about by the winds; late autumn trees without fruit, twice dead, pulled up by the roots; raging waves of the sea, foaming up their own shame; wandering stars for whom is reserved the blackness of darkness forever” (Jude 1:12-13). The wicked are not tested because they cannot stand still and are incapable of being refined. As the poor quality flax splinters and the seas cast up mud, the wicked can only respond to divine testing with failure, which would be senseless.
R. Yonatan concludes with a quote from Genesis chapter 39, the story of Joseph being seduced by Potiphar’s wife. This attempted seduction is a Divine test, and while its consequences appear disastrous, its purpose was to refine and elevate him. It was not for Joseph’s glory but God’s because it was through his elevation that God was able to preserve the family of Israel and the lineage of the Messiah.
This second Mashal, or R. Yonatan, describes a potter who checks the contents of his kiln. Checking involves striking the items several times. Only the well-made pots are struck because they will not break under the blows. However, the defective pots are not struck once because they will break even at the slightest touch. Again, the motivation for striking the well-made pots, i.e., for testing the righteous, is unknown. The potter already knows which pots are well-made and which ones are defective.
So, just as with Abraham, why is the test even necessary? The only reason given is that the righteous can withstand the test, and this Divine test is a blow, something painful to be endured. The apostle Paul uses a similar analogy in the book of Romans: “What if God, wanting to show His wrath and to make His power known, endured with much longsuffering the vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, and that He might make known the riches of His glory on the vessels of mercy, which He had prepared beforehand for glory, even us whom He called, not of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles?” (Romans 9:22-24). Striking the well-made pot does not have any refining benefit except to confirm its quality, and that being attributed to its creator. This test is for God’s glory, not ours.
One nuance partly addressed here in Romans 9 deals with free will versus Divine election. The thought of free will is central to Judaism and Christianity, with divergence forming in Christianity around election and salvation. It is a complicated subject and is better discussed separately. But, in these parables, to retain the value, it is important to view God as completely sovereign on every level, especially in His election of those who He deems righteous and those who He calls wicked. Scripture is clear. There are vessels of wrath, and there are vessels of mercy.
The last Mashal by R. Elazar describes a situation in which the owner of two cows needs to place a yoke upon them to carry out a task. The householder naturally chooses a strong cow because he can carry the burden. While R. Yonatan has focused on beating and blowing as a form of divine testing, R. Elazar describes a Divine test as a burden to be carried. Jesus used a similar analogy, saying, “For My yoke is easy and My burden is light” (Matthew 11:30).
This last Mashal takes us in a new direction. A yoke implies that we are employed to carry out God’s work. One does not attach a yoke to an animal unless there is a task to accomplish or a burden to carry. In contrast, in the first two Meshalim, we see an explanation of why the righteous are being tested, and the wicked are not even mentioned. R. Elazar interprets such trials as divinely ordained tasks that must be accomplished, a test of faith and obedience rather than testing our endurance.
And what is our first task? Jesus said: “If anyone desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross daily, and follow Me” (Luke 9:23). In this calling, the wicked are not even chosen, for they by God’s investigation have no purpose. The wicked follow their lusts, but the righteous will deny themselves to follow Christ. And our second and equally important task? “A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another; as I have loved you, that you also love one another. By this all will know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another” (John 13:34-35).
In conclusion, God’s divine testing comes in various forms. The first example shows that beating flax has a refining benefit. God needs to change our nature to conform to His, and this may require us to experience His discipline: “For whom the Lord loves He chastens, and scourges every son whom He receives” (Hebrews 12:6). In the second example, we see that striking a well-made pot does not have any refining benefit. It is simply a confirmation of its quality that is being attributed to its creator. God is glorified. In the last example, we see that Divine testing from God also comes in the form of carrying a burden or a task, our first task being to take up and carry our crosses daily, and the second to obey His commandments that we love each other as Christ has loved us.
Let us close with encouragement, dear brothers and sisters, for God’s immeasurable love for you. Therefore: “Rejoice to the extent that you partake of Christ’s sufferings, that when His glory is revealed, you may also be glad with exceeding joy” (1 Peter 4:13).